Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Article: Lab-grown vs natural diamonds: what is the same, what is different and where the value comes from

Buying guide

Lab-grown vs natural diamonds: what is the same, what is different and where the value comes from

The short answer: a lab-grown diamond is a real diamond. It is the same material as a natural diamond, with the same hardness and the same sparkle. The difference is where it came from. One formed underground over a billion years or more. The other was grown in a machine in a few weeks. That difference in origin is what sets the price and the long-term value.

We sell both, so we have no reason to push you either way. Here are the four things worth understanding.

Diagram comparing how natural and lab-grown diamonds form

Lab-grown vs natural at a glance

Natural diamond Lab-grown diamond
What it is made of Crystallised carbon Crystallised carbon
Hardness 10 on the Mohs scale 10 on the Mohs scale
Sparkle Decided by the cut Decided by the cut
Origin Formed deep in the earth Grown in a laboratory
Age Roughly 1 to 3 billion years A few weeks
Supply Limited Can be made to order
Price for the same grades Higher A fraction of the natural price
Resale value Below what you paid, but an established market Very little
Certificate GIA, IGI and others IGI, GIA and others, marked laboratory-grown

1. What is the same, and why?

Both are carbon atoms locked into the same crystal structure. That structure is what makes a diamond a diamond. It is why both are the hardest natural material known, why both bend light the same way, and why both will last for generations.

They are the same because the laboratory copies what the earth does. There are two methods.

  • HPHT (high pressure, high temperature). A small diamond seed is placed in carbon and put under enormous pressure and heat, much like the conditions deep underground.
  • CVD (chemical vapour deposition). A seed is placed in a chamber filled with carbon-rich gas. The carbon settles on the seed and the crystal grows layer by layer.

Either way, what comes out is rough diamond. It is then cut and polished by the same cutters using the same tools.

A lab-grown diamond is not a fake. Cubic zirconia and moissanite are different materials that look similar. A lab-grown diamond is diamond.

2. What is different?

To the eye, nothing. Put the two side by side with the same grades and nobody can tell them apart. That includes jewellers using a loupe.

The differences are in the detail a laboratory can measure.

  • Origin and age. A natural diamond is one of the oldest things you will ever hold. A lab-grown diamond is new.
  • Trace elements. Most natural diamonds contain a tiny amount of nitrogen picked up as they formed. Most lab-grown diamonds contain almost none.
  • Growth pattern. A crystal grown in a machine builds up differently from one formed in the earth. Specialist equipment can read that pattern.
  • Inclusions. Natural stones tend to hold small crystals and feathers. HPHT stones can hold tiny specks of metal from the growth process.

None of this changes how the diamond looks or wears on the hand.

3. Where does the value of each come from?

Natural diamonds

The value comes from rarity. There is a fixed amount in the ground, they are expensive to find and mine, and large clean stones are scarce. There is also a long-established market for buying them back. You will not get what you paid in a shop, because retail prices include making, VAT and margin. But a good natural diamond will always be worth something to the trade.

Lab-grown diamonds

The value is in what you get for your money on the day. Because they can be made to order, prices follow the cost of making them, and that cost keeps coming down as the technology improves. Lab-grown prices have fallen a long way in the last few years. The resale market is very thin.

So the choice is straightforward. With lab-grown you get a larger or higher grade diamond for the budget, and you should treat the money as spent. With natural you pay more for a smaller stone, and you own something rare that keeps part of its worth.

Neither is an investment in the way shares or property are. Buy the ring to be worn.

4. How do you know which one you are buying?

This is the part people ask about least and should ask about most. If the eye cannot tell them apart, you are relying on paperwork and on the person selling it.

  • The certificate says so. An independent grading report states clearly whether the diamond is natural or laboratory-grown.
  • The stone is inscribed. Certified lab-grown diamonds carry a tiny laser inscription on the edge that identifies them as laboratory-grown, along with the report number. A jeweller can show it to you under magnification.
  • The trade can test. Jewellers and laboratories use screening instruments that separate natural from lab-grown.
  • The seller has to tell you. In the UK a lab-grown diamond must be described as one. If a listing just says diamond with no certificate, ask.

One note on grading. IGI grades lab-grown diamonds on the same colour and clarity scales as natural diamonds, and it is the certificate you will see most often on lab-grown stones. For how to read those grades, see the 4Cs of diamonds explained.

Which should you choose?

Lab-grown tends to suit you if size and quality for the budget matter most, you would rather put the saving towards the wedding or a home, and you are not concerned about resale.

Natural tends to suit you if the rarity and age of the stone mean something to you, you want the ring to hold some value, or it is intended as an heirloom.

Plenty of couples simply ask each other. It is a better conversation to have before the ring is bought than after.

Common questions

Are lab-grown diamonds real diamonds?

Yes. They are crystallised carbon with the same structure, hardness and sparkle as natural diamonds. Only the origin is different.

Can a jeweller tell a lab-grown diamond from a natural one?

Not by eye or with a loupe. It takes screening equipment, or the certificate and the laser inscription on the stone.

Will a lab-grown diamond pass a diamond tester?

Yes. A standard diamond tester checks how the stone conducts heat, and a lab-grown diamond conducts heat exactly as a natural one does.

Do lab-grown diamonds hold their value?

Not well. Prices have fallen as production has become cheaper, and there is little resale market. Buy one for what it gives you now, not for what it might fetch later.

Do lab-grown diamonds go cloudy or fade?

No. A lab-grown diamond is as hard and as stable as a natural one. Like any diamond it will pick up grease from everyday wear and will sparkle again once cleaned.

Why are lab-grown diamonds cheaper?

They can be produced to order in weeks, so supply is not limited. Natural diamonds have to be found and mined, and the supply is finite.

Compare them for yourself

Our diamond search lists both, each with its certificate. Browse natural diamonds or lab-grown diamonds and compare what the same budget buys in each.

Then read how much to spend on an engagement ring and how to make sure a wedding ring will sit flush.

To see both side by side in person, call +44 7898 659493 or visit us at 81 to 83 Spencer Street in Birmingham's Jewellery Quarter, Monday to Saturday, 9am to 6pm.

Read more

Buying guide

Will a wedding ring sit flush with your engagement ring? Decide before you buy

Every engagement ring ends up next to a wedding ring. If the stone is set too low, a straight wedding band cannot sit flush against it. What to check before the engagement ring is made.

Read more
Budget

How much should you spend on an engagement ring? A UK guide

There is no rule. The three months' salary idea came from advertising. What couples in the UK actually spend, what the money pays for, and seven ways to get more ring for the same budget.

Read more